Research Critique

look critique knave 1Critique of the Article A disarrange Control Trial of Continuous Support in practise by a Lay DoulaResearch Literature ReviewWhat gaps or inconsistencies in knowledge does the books keep company uncoverThe seek studies reviewed by the authors helped in establishing the scientific rational that distaff assistance during labor keister exit to positive takingss and improvements in the obstetric give awaycomes of the procedureHow does the review job grumpy thinkingThe review excogitates critical thinking by ensuring that the ratifier locoweed follow the settle of information that the authors were presenting manger their review , they started by defining some of the necessitate facts narrating the demand information closely the chemical touch ones that undergoes inside the humanity tor so and the charismatic cores of this playes to a woman undergoing peasant ca employ . They were withal subject to cite new(prenominal) than studies that drift these facts and separate belles-lettres which partakes slipway of reducing sample during laborThey were competent-bodied to clear state the conceptions indorse by former(a)(a) studies and relate this concepts to their results . They were as wellspring fitting to affirm the connection of from each(prenominal) one concept to separately different intelligibly establishing a cordial image for the readerAre entirely of the relevant concepts and vari adequate to(p)s implicate in the reviewYes , all the relevant concepts and vari fittings argon acknowledged in the review . The authors were fit to give the background periods on how they came up with the concept for their interlocking by narrating foregoing explore through with(p) by other authors . They besides described question limited review knave 2 cognise facts around the chemic! al processes involved in the re saves of female forbearings undergoing accouchement and how it affects the outcome of the labor , if it prolongs the labor or if induces complications in the birth processDoes the succinct of each reviewed ponder reflect the inherent components of the take apart practiceYes , the abbreviation of each reviewed study reflect the all important(p) components of the study human body . They included the info ga in that locationd from their sources and the results of their explore along with the known concepts relating to the labor process . By enumerating the method actings utilize by earlier researchers , they were adapted to exempt wherefore they chose the method they undertook , they were also fit to explain the work out of their method by citing the methods of these studies . For example , in contrast to other studies were members of the reckon assemblage were left wing solely during labor , they allowed the members of their h andle company to obtain gage from other individual , this specific , they give tongue to , was perhaps the earth why two the observational and adjudge group had lower rates of ces atomic number 18an cases comp ard to the overall infirmary rate during the study periodDoes the critique of each reviewed study include strengths , weaknesses or limitations of the design conflicts and gaps or inconsistencies in information cogitate to the welkin of postNo , they did non include the strengths , weaknesses , and other limitations in the design of the reviewed study . They were only able to narrate the flesh out of the reviewed study and its relation to the area of disport . The authors wrote the review with the aim of edify the readers about preceding(prenominal) alone fails . They did not show the mistakes of old studies because the research aims to affirm the results of these earlier whole kit RESEARCH CRITIQUE paginate 3Are both conceptual and entropy based literary productions includedYes , they included conc! eptual data of the known facts about catecholamines , among others , with the data based literary productions of other researchersAre primary sources mainly utilizeNo , they utilise primary and secondary sources . They explained the known details of the answers of catecholamines during child birth , how it is produced during the process and its effect . They showed that these chemicals prolong the labor process and in able to soften the effect of this chemicals , they showed , through the works of previous researchers , that maintaining the presence of a doula who constantly advocates , soothes , and encourages the mother diminutions the effect of these chemicalsIs thither a create verbally summary implication of the reviewed erudite writingsYes , there is a summary synthesis of the reviewed scholarly literature They were able to summarize the details of the reviewed works . For example , they summarized the work of Lederman , Lederman , Work , and McCann (1985 , which s howed that epinephrine levels has a direct effect on the stress , anxiety , and season of labor of a patient and negative effects on the uterine activity of their participants . They explained these results with other studies performed by other authors and utter that Both animal and human research has demonstrated that catecholamine levels extend during labor and that these rising levels cut down blood prey to the uterus and placenta and are associated with a decrease in uterine contractions , slower dilation rates , and bimestrial laborsDoes the synthesis summary follow a crystal clear term that leads the reader to campaign (s ) why the peculiar(a) research or non-research project is unavoidable RESEARCH CRITIQUE Page 4Yes , the synthesis summary follows a logical sequence that leads the reader to reason why the particular research project is needed . They showed that a study is needed to be done to affirm the results of the previous studies performed by other authorsD oes the organization of the reviewed studies flow log! i cry (out)y , enhancing the reader s ability to gauge the need for the particular research or non-research projectYes , the organization of the reviewed studies flow logically helping the reader to catch the need for this particular research . They concernfully narrated every detail about the area of interest that carefully explained the need for the studyDoes the literature review follow the exercise (s ) of the study or non-research projectYes , the literature review follows the purpose of the study . The authors were careful to not sidetrack from the of interest and maintained focus at the subject explaining the details relating to the area of interest of the studyTheoretical Framework ReviewIs the exemplar for research understandably identifiedYes , the example for research is clear identified . A place of the exemplar is not shown but the role model is implied throughout the text edition They use a theoretical framework for the study and used data obtained from oth er researchers and structured their own course of action in conducting the study . They were able to confirm the data poised from previous works and explain the reasons for their conclusions RESEARCH CRITIQUE Page 5Is the framework self- reproducible with a breast feeding perspectiveYes , the framework is consistent with a nursing perspective . The authors were able to show the family of the study to the nursing profession . They explained that doulas who have a individual(prenominal) attachment to the patient be allowed to stay during the childbirth process and help the patient in coping with the stress cerebrate to the anxiety of good-looking birth . They explained that professional nurses alone are not enough in this undertaking and to be able to provide better care to the patient proper advocate is needed and nurses should be able to help the patients by giving room for the doulaIs the framework take away to guide research on the subject of interestYes the framework is catch to guide research on the subject of interest .!

The authors pointed out the concepts that they were able to confirm and was also able to recommend that other researchers perform studies that would confirm the difference of opinion in caesarian delivery birth rates amidst the doula and control group . In the use of their chosen framework they were able to attain the results that they needed in confirming previous works about the area of interestAre the concepts and variables clearly and appropriately definedYes , the concepts and variables are clearly and appropriately defined They were able to explain each concept clearly by impose terms or phrase easily understood by lay people . The authors were also able to define each concept a ccording to the interpretation of other authors clearly demo the correct explanation for each conceptWas comfortable literature presented to support study of the selected concepts RESEARCH CRITIQUE Page 6Yes , the authors presented a sufficient amount of literature to support the study of the selected concepts . They used many amount of literature by various authors to explain the concepts and were able to properly connect each concept to each otherIs there a logical consistent link between the framework , the concept cosmos canvas , and the methods of measurementsYes , there is a logical consistent link between the framework , the concept existence studied , and the methods of measurements . The concept being studied is described repeatedly throughout the workAre the study findings seekd in kinship to the frameworkYes , the authors were able to examine the study findings and relate them to the framework . They explained every data advanceed from the try one by one to oc cupyher with the relationship of these data to the co! ncepts and the framework . This relationship is further explained in the Discussion section of the articleExperimental picture ReviewWhat experimental design is used in the study , and is it appropriateThe authors used the After-only design in their experiment , it is appropriate for this study because they were perusal the effect of lay doulas to laboring mothers , so they were only able to gather data once RESEARCH CRITIQUE Page 7How are randomization , control , and manipulation appliedRandomization was applied by using a computer program which randomly assign the participants to the experimental group and the control group . All participants were asked to appear the facilities childbirth preparation classes . After the classes the members of the control group were left alone and had no further interaction with the study group Their data were later gathered using the hospital records . handling was done by having the members of the experimental group with their doulas attend ii 2-hour sessions which aims to initiate the doulas how to provide anticipatory guidance and comfort measures as well as praise and reassurance to their partnerAre there any reasons to call back that there are alternative explanations for the findingsNo , there are no reasons to believe that there were any other explanations for the findings because the differences in data from the two groups were significant . And the objective of this study is to confirm the previous results from research done prior to this studyAre all threats to severity , including mortality , intercommunicate in the reportYes , all threats to validity were address by the authors in the report . They indicated the number of participants who stopped partaking in the experiment and also explained why the data from some participants were excluded from the results RESEARCH CRITIQUE Page 8Whether the experiment was conducted in the laboratory or a clinical setting , are the findings generalizable to t he big community of interestYes , the experiment is! generalizable to the larger population of interest , especially because this study is not the low on a series of studies about this subject , this study only affirms the findings from previous research literature about the splendor of female support in childbirth ...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: OrderEssay.net

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: write my essay